Rome: The use of artificial intelligence (AI) in image generation has again sparked controversy following President Donald Trump’s sharing of a digitally altered image presenting him as the Pope. The photograph, generated via AI, was first posted to Trump’s Truth Social media platform before being subsequently shared on the official X account of the White House. This action drew swift criticism from US Cardinal Timothy Dolan, Archbishop of New York.
In a statement made on Sunday, Cardinal Dolan described the image as “not good,” expressing his disapproval of the President’s actions. However, he declined to call for an apology from the White House, opting for a more measured response. This measured approach has itself been a subject of discussion, with some questioning whether it adequately addressed the offence caused to the Catholic community.
The timing of the incident is also significant, occurring less than a week after President Trump attended the funeral of Pope Francis, who passed away last month. The AI image immediately garnered international attention, making headlines in various Italian newspapers. Reactions to the image were mixed, with many expressing outrage and condemnation, whilst others, primarily in right-wing publications, viewed it as a humorous matter. Public opinion, as expressed by pilgrims and tourists in St Peter’s Square, ranged from disbelief and dismay to indifference.
Cardinal Dolan, known for his conservative views, previously delivered an invocation at President Trump’s inauguration. His role in the upcoming conclave to elect the successor to Pope Francis adds further layers to the context of his measured response. The controversy highlights the complex interplay between political figures, religious institutions, and the rapidly evolving capabilities of AI image generation technology.
